By
Chris Meadows
As part of their “21 Cool iPhone Apps” feature, PC Magazine has posted 2-page reviews of both Stanza and eReader. It gives both apps high marks, though Stanza gets half a star more than eReader.
Both reviews contain some factual errors, but they are the sorts of things you need to go in-depth to discover—not things that can be easily discovered in a brief review period. In the eReader review, the reviewer complains:
As with Stanza, which can also read eReader’s PDB and PRC file format, buying current bestsellers for eReader is less than streamlined. That’s because the only source, whichever reader you use, is Fictionwise—a slow, quirky site with an outdated design. So, for example, you may already have a Fictionwise account for Stanza, but you can’t use it for eReader, though both apps use the same domain, store, and file format.
This is, of course, doubly untrue—in addition to Stanza’s Fictionwise store, books can also be bought from the ordinary Fictionwise site and from eReader.com in both cases, and both sites have simplified mobile pages which the reviewer apparently missed.
It’s hard to blame the reviewer for this one, though; Lexcycle’s whole Stanza Fictionwise store deal is way too complicated, and it’s easy to miss what sites you can use the eReader client with. Even now, the eReader client’s login process is confusing, and there’s nothing on the screen that says you can log into either your eReader or your Fictionwise account just by entering the different userIDs.
Another error is that when the reviewer counts Stanza’s ability to read more formats than eReader as a plus, he apparently does not notice the way that non-ePub file formats converted over from the desktop lose all formatting. Perhaps he was less focused on these issues than on readability at all.
In any event, it is nice to see an e-book client that is not Stanza getting some coverage in addition to the Lexcycle reader’s rosy glow of publicity. It would have been nice if they could have covered Bookshelf, as well, since it is a much better reader for non-ePub books than Stanza, but they could only cover 21 apps after all.
4 Comments »
Posted in
Apple,
Chris Meadows,
E-books and all that,
Fictionwise,
e-book,
e-book ergonomics,
e-books,
e-books and other digipubs,
eReader,
ebook,
ebooks,
iPhone and iPod Touch,
iPod Touch | |
Permanent link